| 
| Looks
at |
| |
Partner
profiles |
|
Limitations
of joint ventures |
| |
Key
areas of partner evaluation |
Our
framework is now a firm one; we are clear on the industry segment
and the country in question, we have a reasonable idea of the nature
of the joint venture or alliance which is both desirable and possible
and we've also developed a desired partner profile. Since there
has also been personal interaction in the country in question, there's
also a good chance that we have a short listed a couple of potential
alliance partners. A lot remains though...we have to find the right
one.
Determining
the Desired Partner Profile
-
Match the firms in question to the desired partner profile by
a structured questionnaire.
Focus
on:
- Size
- Ownership
- Financial status
- Capacity to invest
- Technology levels
- Market access
- Product range
- Personnel relations
- Political affiliations
-
Examine the potential partner's strategic interest. Is there synergy
here vis-à-vis our strategic interest?
-
Some more examples of strategic alliances include:
- France's Renault and Sweden's Volvo
- Daimler-Benz and Mitsubishi
- Fujitsu, Japan's largest computer company, has acquired Britain's
ICL
- Britain's largest glass maker Pilkington has joined with France's
Saint Gobain and Japan's Nippon Sheet Glass
- Italy's Olivetti is distributing mainframe computers for Hitachi
and developing laptops with Japan's YE Data.
Factors
to Consider When in Search of a Foreign Collaborator
-
Market access - image, brand popularity
-
Technology - current, future
-
Rapport/synergy
-
Company size/product range
-
Investment
-
Currency
-
Logistics
-
Language
| Toys
'R' Us: Local Strength |
When
Toys 'R' Us, one of America's most successful store chains,
broke into Japan's famously restricted and over-regulated
retailing industry, it wisely allied itself with McDonald's
which acquired a 20% stake in the Japanese operation of Toys
'R' Us. Den Fujita, McDonald's' president in Japan, is one
of the best retailers there. |
Joint
Ventures / Alliances - Limitations
One
has to consider whether a new joint venture will be able to develop
its own export markets if this is deemed important.
| IBM
and Coca-Cola: Limitations of Joint Venture |
With
IBM and Coca-Cola in Nigeria, a joint venture could not export
to neighbouring African countries, as other subsidiaries of
IBM and Coca-Cola were already in existence there. |
| Seeking
Global Brand Presence: The Japanese Example |
Japan's
move from being component suppliers to collaborators in the
United Kingdom involved strategic thinking. The Japanese business
relationship with Europe started with the supply of components
to European businesses. Soon Japan wanted to move ahead and
establish their own brands in these markets. Thus gradually,
Sony, Matsushita and Mitsubishi set up local manufacturing
operations in the United Kingdom. Naturally, the influx of
Japanese brands posed a threat to the European industry. Quick
to respond, Japanese companies like Toshiba and Hitachi simply
searched for UK partners. But such a movement of manufacturing
operations across the continents translated into high cost
incidence both in money and quality terms. But Japan saw these
costs as intrinsic to the need to establish brand positions
and distribution strengths in the UK. |
| Toshiba
and Motorola: Forging a successful alliance |
Toshiba
and Motorola's association goes back to the mid-1980s, in
the development of microprocessors and memory chips. Frequent
interactions between the two companies led to the creation
of a successful, healthy alliance. |
| Siemens
Corning: Combining Strengths |
Combining
the strengths of the two companies contributed considerably
to the success of Corning's joint venture with Siemens to
produce fiber optic cable. Corning contributes the patented
technology involved and Siemens the finance and distribution
network, as well as the technology for the required equipment. |
| Corning:
Multiple Alliances |
- Corning
obtains over half its profits from a host of alliances,
over two-thirds of them with foreign companies. Some examples
are:
-
BICC Britain for optical fibre
-
Giba-Geigy (Switzerland) for medical diagnostic equipment
and materials
-
Cie Financiere des Fibres Optiques (France) for optical
fibre
-
Siemens (West Germany) for optical fibre cable
-
Finimi (Belgium) for specialty glass
-
Asahi Glass (Japan) for glass for TV picture tubes and cookware
-
Beijing Electronic Glass Engineering Technology School (China)
for glass for TV picture tubes
-
NGK Insulators (Japan) for ceramics for catalytic converters
-
Samsung Group (South Korea) for glass for TV picture tubes
-
Australian Consolidated Industries (Australia) for cookware
-
Metal Manufacturers, Amalgamated Wireless Austral-Asia (Australia)
for optical fibre
|
| IBM:
Numerous Japanese Links |
IBM's
operations in Japan are successful where it shares distribution
units with Ricoh and computer-integrated manufacturing with
Nippon Telephone. IBM is also active in a tie- up with Fuji
Bank for financial systems marketing. |
| Sandoz-
Sankyo: Happy Ending |
When
the Sandoz-Sankyo alliance was terminated, this resulted in
the establishment of an independent business for Sandoz in
Japan, making it one of Japan's leading pharmaceutical companies.
The Japanese partners in the alliance had meanwhile gained
access to Western European markets, which business they continue
to build on.
Bayer's
alliance with Takeda ended in a similar successful fashion. |
| Glaxo:
Planned Networking |
Glaxo,
the British pharmaceutical company, has not established a
full business system in each country of its operation. The
company has not, for example, built a full-scale sales and
service network in Japan. Glaxo instead formed alliances with
Japanese companies and exchanged its best products with each
of them. Thus while Glaxo effectively extended the network
of its overseas operations, it continued to focus its own
resources on its already established network in Europe, generating
greater sales there.
Nippon Glaxo (of which Glaxo holds 50%) has recently signed
an agreement with Sankyo and Taisho Pharmaceuticals of Japan
to co-develop Zantac, its best-selling drug, as part of Glaxo's
strategy of licensing out development. |
Research
on strategic alliances shows that :
-
A 50:50 relationship fares much better than an 80:20 one
- The
life of a successful strategic alliance averages seven years
- Successful
alliances often end in a buy-out
The
Next Step: Observation
If
one firm turns out to be better than the other according to the
analysis you have undertaken so far, take the next step only for
that particular firm. If the firm does no match up to these "subjective"
criteria, then apply them to the second firm and decide between
the two.
If
both firms match up equally well on the parameter; detailed above,
the next step will have to be undertaker for both firms and a selection
made depending on the outcome of this further analysis.
-
See the firm at work
- Watch
its people in action
- Examine
its processes in operation

Key
Areas for Partner Evaluation
-
Management style
- Willingness
to share control
- Willingness
to adapt/compromise
- Trust,
openness, patience
- Compatibility
- will the "chemistry" work?

| BHP:
Choosing the leadership |
Says
one young Chinese employee headhunted by BHP in 1988 at the
age of 31 to be its chief representative in China "BHP
recognises that Beijing needs someone who is not out of the
straight BHF mould...business in China is based or relationships,
and how well you develop these relationships is what gives
you opportunities...foreign companies have had trouble with
this because they pay too much attention to contracts...they
also assume because it is a joint venture, the Chinese will
do it. This is not necessarily so, as the parties often do
not have a strong understanding of each other's needs...as
reflected in the Chinese proverb 'Same bed, different dreams."
|
We
have thus developed a structured approach to partner search from
the perspective of both the home and host country firms of developing
or developed countries. We have also seen various examples of different
joint ventures and alliances around the world.
|